Cheese toasties usually flip soggy or burnt with butter, however a standard kitchen ingredient may help the bread crisp up, and the cheese soften correctly each time.

Toasties will crisp up and soften higher if made with mayonnaise as an alternative of butter (Picture: Katherine McPhillips)
Toasties are my favorite lunch as they’re crispy, tacky and the proper consolation meal to fill you up on a wet day. It tends to be very easy to make a toastie, however they usually prove greasy, soggy, and even burned when you make them with butter.
Butter may go properly on sandwiches, nevertheless it comprises milk solids that don’t deal with warmth very properly and can start to smoke up rapidly as soon as you start cooking your toastie. Utilizing butter won’t prepare dinner bread evenly, so you find yourself with a toastie which is pale in some locations on the bread whereas being charred to bits in different areas. As an alternative, I’ve found {that a} toastie shall be a lot tastier when you simply swap butter for mayonnaise, as it can assist the bread toast up correctly.
We use your sign-up to supply content material in methods you have consented to and to enhance our understanding of you. This will embrace adverts from us and third events based mostly on our understanding. You’ll be able to unsubscribe at any time. Learn our Privateness Coverage

Mayonnaise comprises oils that toasts bread higher than butter does (Picture: Katherine McPhillips)
Why use mayonnaise as an alternative of butter to make a toastie?
Mayonnaise is usually manufactured from oil, which helps it brown extra persistently than butter so you’re going to get a greater texture with out the bread burning too rapidly.
It helps a toastie prepare dinner extra evenly and creates a really crisp texture, so your sandwich comes out completely golden brown with little or no effort.
When mayonnaise is heated, its flavour turns into very delicate, so there is no such thing as a want to fret about it tasting eggy.
I’ve been making toasties for years, and I can affirm that this can give a toastie a wealthy and crisp end that can make a sandwich seem like it got here straight from a restaurant.
You will have:
- Two slices of bread
- Two teaspoons of mayonnaise
- One teaspoon of Dijon mustard
- 60g of cheddar cheese
- 60g of Emmental cheese
- Some other toppings you want (ham, onions, chives, chilli flakes, and so on)
- A toastie maker or frying pan
Sourdough bread is usually thought-about the very best bread to make use of for toasties because it has a agency construction, so it won’t go soggy as soon as the cheese begins to soften.
That stated, it’s usually finest to make use of no matter bread you will have obtainable, and I made a decision to make use of whole-grain as a result of it’s my favorite. The one bread I’d keep away from is brioche, because it tends to burn rapidly and grow to be fairly greasy when heated with cheese.
You should utilize any cheese you want for this recipe, however I extremely suggest utilizing slightly cheddar as a result of it has a pointy style that provides a toastie a bolder and richer flavour.
Nevertheless, cheddar tends to separate when heated, which might make a toastie really feel greasy when you use an excessive amount of, so in my view, it’s higher to stability it with one other cheese.
I like Emmental as a result of it has a very creamy style and barely extra moisture than cheddar, which helps it soften easily and prevents it from turning into oily.

You can also make a toastie in a toastie maker or in a frying pan (Picture: Katherine McPhillips)
Methodology:
To start, grate the cheese you have to. It’s higher to do it your self, as pre-grated or sliced cheese tends to be coated in starch that slows down melting and may make a toastie style grainy.
Unfold a skinny layer of mayonnaise on one facet of every slice of bread. Then unfold mustard, or another condiments you want, on the opposite facet.
Place the grated cheese and another toppings on the mustard-covered facet of the bread. Ensure the mayonnaise-coated sides face outward earlier than sandwiching the slices collectively.
You’ll be able to then place the sandwich in a toastie maker, set the timer, and await it to be prepared. Nevertheless, it’s also very straightforward to make a toastie in a frying pan. Place the pan on a low warmth and prepare dinner all sides for 3 to 4 minutes till golden brown.
You do not want oil to make a toastie, because the bread and mayonnaise will toast on their very own. Utilizing cooking oil can usually make a toastie greasy, so it’s best prevented.
Place your toastie on a plate, and it must be completely golden, crispy, and style higher than each different toastie you will have made earlier than.


















Leave a Reply