Because the nation’s love for pies continues unabated, one author examined steak pies from Waitrose, M&S, Tesco, Sainsbury’s and Aldi to seek out the perfect – and a few had been much better than others
Waitrose’s steak pie was scrumptious (Picture: Emilia Randall)
For a rustic enthusiastic about pies, discovering Britain’s most interesting grocery store steak pie is critical enterprise.
Pies, whether or not candy or savoury, have been embedded in English meals tradition since a minimum of the thirteenth century. But for numerous Brits, nothing beats the timeless steak and ale selection.
We use your sign-up to supply content material in methods you have consented to and to enhance our understanding of you. This will likely embody adverts from us and third events based mostly on our understanding. You’ll be able to unsubscribe at any time. Learn our Privateness Coverage
That will help you navigate this week-long pastry celebration, I took on the problem of testing each grocery store steak pie accessible, so you may know precisely the place your cash’s finest spent.
I tasted steak pies from MandS, Waitrose, Aldi, Sainsbury’s and Tesco to find which affords the proper steadiness of worth and flavour.
My standards included flaky pastry, a considerable amount of steak, sturdy and satisfying style, and respectable portion sizing for the value.
Marks and Spencer stands as a British stalwart, and rightfully so. Being the most costly pie examined, my expectations had been naturally elevated – making my disappointment all of the extra pronounced.
Firstly, health-conscious customers ought to take notice – past the steak and pastry issues, this accommodates an eye-watering 6 grams of salt.
I attempted the large 4 supermarkets’ steak and ale pies (Picture: Emilia Randall)
Inexplicably, my pie emerged from the oven burnt, necessitating some emergency remedial work earlier than consumption – specifically scraping the blackened prime straight into the bin.
The packaging indicated it required half-hour at 180C fan. My oven might need been misbehaving, nevertheless it was fully charred when these half-hour had been up.
Relating to style, the filling ranked among the many most sturdy – there was sufficient real steak inside to make it really feel like a correct pie, and it was something however bland, with the ale flavour coming by clearly.
The pastry was its weak spot – being considerably insipid and missing adequate crumbliness for my liking.
As anticipated, Waitrose got here up trumps. This steak pie was a transparent champion.
The pastry was crumbly, brief and filled with flavour. The steak filling was hearty and possessed an impressive depth of style.
This additionally featured the best precise steak amount per pie – with every chunk providing a considerable chunk of meat.
Sainsbury’s steak pie got here an in depth second (Picture: Emilia Randall)
Importantly, this one did not scorch – it baked completely within the oven and got here out with a super golden end.
It simply served two folks with a serving to of veg, and would offer an uncomplicated, budget-friendly weeknight meal once you’re not up for spending ages toiling over a sizzling range.
Aldi’s steak bake proved underwhelming. The pastry was flaky and satisfactory, however that is the place the compliments cease. The steak filling had completely no style in any way.
My fellow taster Pierre likened it to “receiving a heat hug from a relative you do not actually like.”
This was bang on. At £1.15, it hardly damages your funds – however equally affords valuable little in alternate.
This undeniably delivered the strongest ale style of all of the pies, whereas its pastry was much less “puff” and extra crumbly than described – which suited me completely.
It supplied a genuinely gratifying filling, with no pastry intruding on the plentiful quantity of steak and gravy in each mouthful.
Aside from that, there was minimal separating this pie from the others, and it landed squarely within the common bracket.
The puff pastry achieved a ravishing golden, crisp color and the filling was hearty and filled with style.
Regardless of experiencing a considerably soggy backside, this pie is a very dependable possibility and affords excellent worth for cash.
This featured one of many extra delicately flavoured fillings, with additional notes past typical gravy rising – together with even a contact of herbs and spices enhancing the ale and steak.
It baked to perfection inside the beneficial time and undoubtedly seemed spectacular. I’d purchase it once more with out second thought.
The M&S pie burnt within the oven (Picture: Emilia Randall)
It’s abundantly evident to me who comes out on prime and who disappoints. Aldi claims final place, attributable to its underwhelming absence of flavour.
Tesco trailed carefully afterwards. I used to be stunned, having anticipated a greater displaying contemplating it was the priciest selection – it was a decent pie, nevertheless it completely did not warrant bearing the steepest price ticket.
Following was MandS, then Sainsbury’s – the latter proving a critical challenger for first place – but its soggy backside finally value it victory.
Maybe much more unexpectedly, Waitrose proved inexpensive than each MandS and Tesco, whereas concurrently offering the perfect pie of the bunch.
It delivered excellent flavour, ample proportions and memorable style that absolutely warranted its value, not like numerous different pies that fairly merely did not provide worth for cash.
For anybody on the lookout for a budget-friendly pie indulgence at dwelling, Waitrose’s pie receives an unreserved endorsement.
Leave a Reply